Should dealerships follow OEM-recommended maintenance intervals or adopt more frequent service schedules?
Answered at 22:00 in Fixed Ops Friday w/ Dave Rogers, Tully Williams, Ed Roberts, & Richard Lupo | Daily Dealer Live · Car Dealership Guy Podcast
Should dealerships follow OEM-recommended maintenance intervals or adopt more frequent service schedules?
There is genuine disagreement among dealership leaders on this question. While Tully Williams advocated for strictly adhering to OEM-recommended maintenance intervals —typically one-year intervals set by factory engineers—three other panelists pushed for more aggressive schedules, including oil changes every six months, to better align with how customers actually use their vehicles.
The Factory Standard Argument
Tully Williams took a firm position: manufacturers engineer their maintenance intervals based on extensive testing and real-world data, and dealerships should respect that expertise rather than second-guess it. OEM engineers deliberately set intervals to balance durability, cost, and customer value, and deviating from those standards risks undermining the integrity of the vehicle warranty and the automaker's research.
This perspective treats the factory standard as a baseline of trust—if a manufacturer says a vehicle's oil is good for 12 months, overriding that decision without explicit customer agreement could expose the dealership to liability and damage relationships with the OEM supply chain.
The Advanced Service Schedule Perspective
The three other panelists took a different view: customers do not always drive their vehicles in the conditions OEMs assume when they design maintenance schedules. Stop-and-go city driving, towing, or extreme temperatures can degrade fluid faster than a manufacturer's one-year projection.
Full answer and detailsRead the whole answer, key facts and every other question from this episode
In short
There is genuine disagreement among dealership leaders on this question.
Guest · Fixed Ops Friday w/ Dave Rogers, Tully Williams, Ed Roberts, & Richard Lupo | Daily Dealer Live · Car Dealership Guy Podcast · answer at 22:00
Key takeaways
- Tully Williams took a firm position: manufacturers engineer their maintenance intervals based on extensive testing and real-world data, and dealerships should respect that expertise rather than second-guess it.
- The three other panelists took a different view: customers do not always drive their vehicles in the conditions OEMs assume when they design maintenance schedules.
The full answer · about 1 min
There is genuine disagreement among dealership leaders on this question. While Tully Williams advocated for strictly adhering to OEM-recommended maintenance intervals —typically one-year intervals set by factory engineers—three other panelists pushed for more aggressive schedules, including oil changes every six months, to better align with how customers actually use their vehicles.
The Factory Standard Argument
Tully Williams took a firm position: manufacturers engineer their maintenance intervals based on extensive testing and real-world data, and dealerships should respect that expertise rather than second-guess it. OEM engineers deliberately set intervals to balance durability, cost, and customer value, and deviating from those standards risks undermining the integrity of the vehicle warranty and the automaker's research.
This perspective treats the factory standard as a baseline of trust—if a manufacturer says a vehicle's oil is good for 12 months, overriding that decision without explicit customer agreement could expose the dealership to liability and damage relationships with the OEM supply chain.
The Advanced Service Schedule Perspective
The three other panelists took a different view: customers do not always drive their vehicles in the conditions OEMs assume when they design maintenance schedules. Stop-and-go city driving, towing, or extreme temperatures can degrade fluid faster than a manufacturer's one-year projection.
More answers from this episode
- 10:00How has OEM data sharing with parts suppliers impacted automotive parts availability in dealerships?
- 13:48Why are repair orders declining in automotive dealerships?
- 15:00What role does customer friction play in repair order decline compared to market availability?
- 16:15How should dealership service departments answer incoming phone calls to improve customer retention?
- 21:00What percentage of routine vehicle service will migrate to mobile service outside dealership locations?
- 24:00Should dealerships prioritize gaining more customer demand or eliminating customer friction in service operations?