How does post-Chevron deference affect the durability of SEC digital asset guidance?
Answered at 8:21 in Karen Ubell on SEC/CFTC Guidance and the CLARITY Act's Final Mile · Form & Structure
How does post-Chevron deference affect the durability of SEC digital asset guidance?
The SEC guidance now carries more authority because it is commission guidance rather than just staff guidance, having gone through all commission channels. However, in a post-Chevron world, courts have already disregarded staff guidance entirely, as seen in Florida cases where judges ignored SEC positions on coins being non-securities. This suggests more challenges ahead even for higher-authority guidance.
Full answer and detailsRead the whole answer, key facts and every other question from this episode
In short
The SEC guidance now carries more authority because it is commission guidance rather than just staff guidance, having gone through all commission channels.
Karen Ubell, Securities and Crypto Law Expert · Karen Ubell on SEC/CFTC Guidance and the CLARITY Act's Final Mile · Form & Structure · answer at 8:21
Key takeaways
- The SEC guidance now carries more authority because it is commission guidance rather than just staff guidance, having gone through all commission channels.
Quote to remember
“I think that just encourages people to keep building and doing what they want to do, but tell you nothing about it.”
— Karen Ubell
The full answer · about 1 min
The SEC guidance now carries more authority because it is commission guidance rather than just staff guidance, having gone through all commission channels. However, in a post-Chevron world, courts have already disregarded staff guidance entirely, as seen in Florida cases where judges ignored SEC positions on coins being non-securities. This suggests more challenges ahead even for higher-authority guidance.
Key facts
- 10-year anniversary of the SAFT white paper (mentioned as coming soon for celebration)
- SEC rejected broker-dealer ATS applications for over 10 years, with only Prometheum/Prometheus emerging as a special purpose broker dealer that made it through
People, companies and topics mentioned
More answers from this episode
- 4:07How does the SEC's new guidance relate to the SAFT framework that Karen Ubell authored?
- 12:12What does the SEC guidance mean for tokenized securities like those offered by Shuras?
- 16:00What is the SEC's position on express and explicit promises in the digital asset guidance?
- 16:00What are the risks of the SEC guidance's disclosure-light framework for the crypto industry?
- 18:18What are the main differences between SEC guidance and the Clarity Act for digital assets?