What is the typical failure rate for windows and doors during certification testing?
Answered at 10:51 in John Warburton - ER Certification Ltd · Glazing Insider
What is the typical failure rate for windows and doors during certification testing?
The chances of products passing certification testing without any issues are remarkably slim. Around 70% of windows and doors fail per testing visit when manufacturers submit samples for weather, security, and performance evaluations. These failures stem from fabrication errors, component defects, or other manufacturing issues that only surface under controlled testing conditions.
When windows and doors arrive at certification labs, they face rigorous testing protocols that expose problems invisible during standard factory quality checks. As John Warburton explains in the Glazing Insider episode, the failure rate reflects the complexity of fenestration products—each component must function flawlessly, and a single weak point triggers a failure.
Why fabrication and components matter in testing
The high failure rate isn't random. Most failures trace back to specific issues: seals not positioned correctly, components from suppliers that don't meet spec, or assembly problems that manufacturing teams miss during production. The certification process acts as an unforgiving checkpoint that catches what internal quality control may have overlooked.
A window that seems perfectly assembled on the factory floor can fail air-tightness testing, water resistance, or security assessment once it reaches the lab. This is precisely why repeated visits are common—manufacturers address failures, resubmit samples, and work through iterations until everything passes. The 70% failure rate per visit underscores that getting fenestration right demands precision at every stage.
"I think we provide a very, very good service. Customers seem to appreciate what we do. I think we're firm but fair."
Full answer and detailsRead the whole answer, key facts and every other question from this episode
In short
The chances of products passing certification testing without any issues are remarkably slim.
John Warburton · John Warburton - ER Certification Ltd · Glazing Insider · answer at 10:51
Key takeaways
- Around 70% of windows and doors fail per testing visit when manufacturers submit samples for weather, security, and performance evaluations.
- When windows and doors arrive at certification labs, they face rigorous testing protocols that expose problems invisible during standard factory quality checks.
- A window that seems perfectly assembled on the factory floor can fail air-tightness testing, water resistance, or security assessment once it reaches the lab.
Quote to remember
“I think we provide a very, very good service. Customers seem to appreciate what we do. I think we're firm but fair.”
— John Warburton
The full answer · about 3 min
The chances of products passing certification testing without any issues are remarkably slim. Around 70% of windows and doors fail per testing visit when manufacturers submit samples for weather, security, and performance evaluations. These failures stem from fabrication errors, component defects, or other manufacturing issues that only surface under controlled testing conditions.
When windows and doors arrive at certification labs, they face rigorous testing protocols that expose problems invisible during standard factory quality checks. As John Warburton explains in the Glazing Insider episode, the failure rate reflects the complexity of fenestration products—each component must function flawlessly, and a single weak point triggers a failure.
Why fabrication and components matter in testing
The high failure rate isn't random. Most failures trace back to specific issues: seals not positioned correctly, components from suppliers that don't meet spec, or assembly problems that manufacturing teams miss during production. The certification process acts as an unforgiving checkpoint that catches what internal quality control may have overlooked.
A window that seems perfectly assembled on the factory floor can fail air-tightness testing, water resistance, or security assessment once it reaches the lab. This is precisely why repeated visits are common—manufacturers address failures, resubmit samples, and work through iterations until everything passes. The 70% failure rate per visit underscores that getting fenestration right demands precision at every stage.
"I think we provide a very, very good service. Customers seem to appreciate what we do. I think we're firm but fair."
More answers from this episode
- 0:20How did early experience in PVC window manufacturing during the 1980s shape understanding of fenestration production?
- 8:28What is the biggest change in the fenestration industry over the past 40 years?
- 15:14Why are trickle vents problematic in modern thermally efficient windows?
- 21:36What is the PLC scheme and how does it differ from other thermal performance certification databases?
- 22:57How many product approvals are currently registered on the PLC scheme database?
- 25:19Why does ER Certification not engage in fire door certification despite industry demand?
- 28:11How did joining ER Certification become a turning point in a long fenestration career?