Why did post-COVID private equity investments in lumber and building materials often fail compared to pre-Great Recession and post-Great Recession periods?
Answered at 5:17 in Private Equity: The Curious and Incurious · Hire Smarter™ with Tony Misura
Why did post-COVID private equity investments in lumber and building materials often fail compared to pre-Great Recession and post-Great Recession periods?
Pre-Great Recession, private equity was strategic and selective with buy-and-hold strategies. After 2008, talented industry operators started their own ventures backed by PE. However, COVID made lumber look like easy money—shooting fish in a barrel. This attracted investors with no strategy, no industry understanding, and no long-term commitment, only seeking five to seven-year exits. Rising housing demand created false security, making even poor operators appear successful, and many new entrants lacked the operating platform and strategy needed to navigate commodity volatility and housing start dynamics.
Full answer and detailsRead the whole answer, key facts and every other question from this episode
In short
Pre-Great Recession, private equity was strategic and selective with buy-and-hold strategies.
Russ Cathrine, Senior Executive, Lumber and Build Materials Products at Do It Best · Private Equity: The Curious and Incurious · Hire Smarter™ with Tony Misura · answer at 5:17
Key takeaways
- Pre-Great Recession, private equity was strategic and selective with buy-and-hold strategies.
Quote to remember
“It's not private equity is bad. That's like saying Republicans are bad or Democrats are bad or whatever. There's some great actors, there's some average actors, and there's some poor and bad actors.”
— Russ Cathrine
The full answer · about 3 min
Pre-Great Recession, private equity was strategic and selective with buy-and-hold strategies. After 2008, talented industry operators started their own ventures backed by PE. However, COVID made lumber look like easy money—shooting fish in a barrel. This attracted investors with no strategy, no industry understanding, and no long-term commitment, only seeking five to seven-year exits. Rising housing demand created false security, making even poor operators appear successful, and many new entrants lacked the operating platform and strategy needed to navigate commodity volatility and housing start dynamics.
Key facts
- Five to seven year hold horizon commonly used by private equity before returning money to investors
- $100 million business with 12 locations mentioned as example of rural market acquisition
- $2 million salesman compensation in rural yards versus $800,000 commission in metro areas
- 35% of cash rolled out requirement for top-level executives in one acquisition mentioned