Listenly

What is the scale of return fraud and processing costs in the U.S. retail system?

Answered at 21:20 in Will AI Actually Kill Us All? & It’s True–Online Returns Are Getting Harder · Morning Brew Daily

— questions searchable right now

What is the scale of return fraud and processing costs in the U.S. retail system?

Return volume in 2025 reached $850 billion—nearly double the 2020 figure of $428 billion —representing 16% of total retail annual sales. Processing a single return costs retailers an average of 27% of the purchase price, while approximately 9% of all returns, worth $76 billion annually, are fraudulent.

The scale of returns in the U.S. retail system has become a critical operational challenge for merchants across all channels. The explosive growth from $428 billion in 2020 to $850 billion in 2025 signals a structural shift in consumer behavior and retail economics. With returns now accounting for roughly one dollar of every six spent online and in stores, the challenges facing retailers today extend far beyond simple logistics, touching profitability, fraud prevention, and customer trust simultaneously.

The True Cost of Processing Returns

The operational burden of handling returns is substantial. Every return processed by a retailer costs an average of 27% of the original purchase price —a figure that encompasses labor, transportation, inspection, restocking, and technology infrastructure. For a $100 purchase, accepting a return thus costs the retailer $27 in direct processing expenses alone, independent of any refund issued.

This cost structure has prompted major retailers to tighten their return policies. Macy's, for instance, reduced its return window from 365 days to 30 days, signaling a deliberate shift toward shorter acceptance periods that limit the long-tail cost burden. As Morning Brew Daily explores in detail, this trend is industry-wide: nearly 7 in 10 retailers (70%) now charge return fees—up from just 43% five years ago—forcing customers to absorb some of the processing cost themselves.

Fraud: The Hidden Tax on Retailers

Unknown on Morning Brew DailyAll answers from this podcast →
Full answer and detailsRead the whole answer, key facts and every other question from this episode

In short

Return volume in 2025 reached $850 billion—nearly double the 2020 figure of $428 billion —representing 16% of total retail annual sales.

Guest · Will AI Actually Kill Us All? & It’s True–Online Returns Are Getting Harder · Morning Brew Daily · answer at 21:20

Key takeaways

  • Processing a single return costs retailers an average of 27% of the purchase price, while approximately 9% of all returns, worth $76 billion annually, are fraudulent.
  • The scale of returns in the U.S. retail system has become a critical operational challenge for merchants across all channels.
  • The operational burden of handling returns is substantial.
  • This cost structure has prompted major retailers to tighten their return policies.

The full answer · about 1 min

Return volume in 2025 reached $850 billion—nearly double the 2020 figure of $428 billion —representing 16% of total retail annual sales. Processing a single return costs retailers an average of 27% of the purchase price, while approximately 9% of all returns, worth $76 billion annually, are fraudulent.

The scale of returns in the U.S. retail system has become a critical operational challenge for merchants across all channels. The explosive growth from $428 billion in 2020 to $850 billion in 2025 signals a structural shift in consumer behavior and retail economics. With returns now accounting for roughly one dollar of every six spent online and in stores, the challenges facing retailers today extend far beyond simple logistics, touching profitability, fraud prevention, and customer trust simultaneously.

The True Cost of Processing Returns

The operational burden of handling returns is substantial. Every return processed by a retailer costs an average of 27% of the original purchase price —a figure that encompasses labor, transportation, inspection, restocking, and technology infrastructure. For a $100 purchase, accepting a return thus costs the retailer $27 in direct processing expenses alone, independent of any refund issued.

This cost structure has prompted major retailers to tighten their return policies. Macy's, for instance, reduced its return window from 365 days to 30 days, signaling a deliberate shift toward shorter acceptance periods that limit the long-tail cost burden. As Morning Brew Daily explores in detail, this trend is industry-wide: nearly 7 in 10 retailers (70%) now charge return fees—up from just 43% five years ago—forcing customers to absorb some of the processing cost themselves.

Fraud: The Hidden Tax on Retailers

More answers from this episode

 ·  All answers from Morning Brew Daily →
—
—
0:00
0:00