Listenly

What are Saudi Arabia's limited options to address the blockade of all oil export routes?

Answered at 15:00 in Why Gas Prices Just Keep Going Up · The Daily

— questions searchable right now

What are Saudi Arabia's limited options to address the blockade of all oil export routes?

Saudi Arabia faces two constrained paths forward: renew a costly military campaign against the Houthis that already failed once, or pursue diplomacy with an adversary known for maximalist demands and no guarantee of compliance. Neither option breaks the blockade with certainty.

The first option is military. A return to war with the Houthis means Saudi Arabia must force them to back down by combat—a strategy that has already been tried. Saudi Arabia's prior bombing campaign from 2015 onwards did not crush Houthi resolve, and the group has only grown stronger and more entrenched since then. The costs of renewed conflict would be substantial, and there is no indication a second attempt would succeed where the first failed.

The second option is diplomacy. But as Vivian Neerheim reports in the episode, the Houthis have a documented history of tabling maximalist demands during negotiations. They currently hold the upper hand—controlling the Bab al-Mandab Strait and other critical chokepoints—and feel emboldened by their military gains. Even if Saudi Arabia negotiates a settlement, there is no guarantee the agreement would be durable or that the Houthis would honor its terms.

"As long as there is still conflict in the region and as long as they have foes who are still willing and able to attack the pipeline, that will remain a risk."

Vivian Neerheim — Correspondent, The New York Times. Based in Riyadh, she covers geopolitical developments across the Middle East, with deep expertise in the Iran-U.S. conflict and its spillover effects on regional energy security and Gulf Arab strategy.

This statement reflects a deeper structural problem: even a diplomatic agreement cannot fully eliminate the risk to Saudi Arabia's exports as long as hostile actors remain capable of targeting infrastructure. The Houthis, backed by Iran, have demonstrated repeated willingness to attack pipelines and shipping routes —and no treaty can guarantee they will stop if political conditions shift or grievances resurface.

Vivian Neerheim on The DailyAll answers from this podcast →
Full answer and detailsRead the whole answer, key facts and every other question from this episode

In short

Saudi Arabia faces two constrained paths forward: renew a costly military campaign against the Houthis that already failed once, or pursue diplomacy with an adversary known for maximalist demands and no guarantee of compliance.

Vivian Neerheim · Why Gas Prices Just Keep Going Up · The Daily · answer at 15:00

Key takeaways

  • Neither option breaks the blockade with certainty.
  • Vivian Neerheim — Correspondent, The New York Times.
  • This statement reflects a deeper structural problem: even a diplomatic agreement cannot fully eliminate the risk to Saudi Arabia's exports as long as hostile actors remain capable of targeting infrastructure.

Quote to remember

“As long as there is still conflict in the region and as long as they have foes who are still willing and able to attack the pipeline, that will remain a risk.”

— Vivian Neerheim

The full answer · about 1 min

Saudi Arabia faces two constrained paths forward: renew a costly military campaign against the Houthis that already failed once, or pursue diplomacy with an adversary known for maximalist demands and no guarantee of compliance. Neither option breaks the blockade with certainty.

The first option is military. A return to war with the Houthis means Saudi Arabia must force them to back down by combat—a strategy that has already been tried. Saudi Arabia's prior bombing campaign from 2015 onwards did not crush Houthi resolve, and the group has only grown stronger and more entrenched since then. The costs of renewed conflict would be substantial, and there is no indication a second attempt would succeed where the first failed.

The second option is diplomacy. But as Vivian Neerheim reports in the episode, the Houthis have a documented history of tabling maximalist demands during negotiations. They currently hold the upper hand—controlling the Bab al-Mandab Strait and other critical chokepoints—and feel emboldened by their military gains. Even if Saudi Arabia negotiates a settlement, there is no guarantee the agreement would be durable or that the Houthis would honor its terms.

"As long as there is still conflict in the region and as long as they have foes who are still willing and able to attack the pipeline, that will remain a risk."

Vivian Neerheim — Correspondent, The New York Times. Based in Riyadh, she covers geopolitical developments across the Middle East, with deep expertise in the Iran-U.S. conflict and its spillover effects on regional energy security and Gulf Arab strategy.

This statement reflects a deeper structural problem: even a diplomatic agreement cannot fully eliminate the risk to Saudi Arabia's exports as long as hostile actors remain capable of targeting infrastructure. The Houthis, backed by Iran, have demonstrated repeated willingness to attack pipelines and shipping routes —and no treaty can guarantee they will stop if political conditions shift or grievances resurface.

More answers from this episode

 ·  All answers from The Daily →
—
—
0:00
0:00