What legal and bias challenges have emerged around AI scoring tools in recruiting?
Answered at 7:06 in The Messy World of AI-Powered Recruiting Where Nobody Is Happy · The Josh Bersin Company
What legal and bias challenges have emerged around AI scoring tools in recruiting?
Multiple U.S. jurisdictions — including New York State and Illinois — have passed laws requiring companies to prove that their AI scoring and inference tools used in hiring are not biased. Two active lawsuits, one against Stateful and one against Workday, are directly challenging these systems. The question of whether AI recruiting tools systematically discriminate remains largely unresolved across the industry.
States Moved First — and Put the Burden of Proof on Employers
Rather than waiting for federal regulation, individual states acted. New York State and Illinois both enacted legislation requiring organizations deploying AI scoring or inference technology in hiring to demonstrate that those systems are not biased. The burden is on the employer — and, by extension, the vendor — to prove compliance.
This is a significant shift. Before these laws, companies could deploy AI screening tools with little obligation to audit for disparate impact. As Josh Bersin details in this episode of The Josh Bersin Company podcast, the legislative pressure is real and already in force — not a future risk.
Stateful and Workday: Two Lawsuits That Could Define the Entire Sector
Two active lawsuits are now testing whether AI-based candidate scoring constitutes illegal discrimination. One targets Stateful, a company whose systems evaluate candidates based on inferred signals. The other targets Workday, one of the most widely deployed HR platforms in the world — meaning a ruling against Workday could have industry-wide consequences.
Full answer and detailsRead the whole answer, key facts and every other question from this episode
In short
Multiple U.S. jurisdictions — including New York State and Illinois — have passed laws requiring companies to prove that their AI scoring and inference tools used in hiring are not biased.
Josh Bersin · The Messy World of AI-Powered Recruiting Where Nobody Is Happy · The Josh Bersin Company · answer at 7:06
Key takeaways
- Two active lawsuits, one against Stateful and one against Workday, are directly challenging these systems.
- Rather than waiting for federal regulation, individual states acted.
- Two active lawsuits are now testing whether AI-based candidate scoring constitutes illegal discrimination.
The full answer · about 1 min
Multiple U.S. jurisdictions — including New York State and Illinois — have passed laws requiring companies to prove that their AI scoring and inference tools used in hiring are not biased. Two active lawsuits, one against Stateful and one against Workday, are directly challenging these systems. The question of whether AI recruiting tools systematically discriminate remains largely unresolved across the industry.
States Moved First — and Put the Burden of Proof on Employers
Rather than waiting for federal regulation, individual states acted. New York State and Illinois both enacted legislation requiring organizations deploying AI scoring or inference technology in hiring to demonstrate that those systems are not biased. The burden is on the employer — and, by extension, the vendor — to prove compliance.
This is a significant shift. Before these laws, companies could deploy AI screening tools with little obligation to audit for disparate impact. As Josh Bersin details in this episode of The Josh Bersin Company podcast, the legislative pressure is real and already in force — not a future risk.
Stateful and Workday: Two Lawsuits That Could Define the Entire Sector
Two active lawsuits are now testing whether AI-based candidate scoring constitutes illegal discrimination. One targets Stateful, a company whose systems evaluate candidates based on inferred signals. The other targets Workday, one of the most widely deployed HR platforms in the world — meaning a ruling against Workday could have industry-wide consequences.
More answers from this episode
- 0:06How large and costly is the recruiting industry in the United States?
- 7:35How has the rise of ChatGPT and off-the-shelf LLMs disrupted AI recruiting tools?
- 11:05What is the North Korean fraudulent engineer threat to AI-powered hiring?
- 15:29How does AI perform on skills assessment compared to holistic candidate evaluation?
- 19:24What role does industrial-organizational psychology play in the future of AI recruiting?