What is the maximum effective number of metrics and SPIFs in a sales compensation plan before sellers stop engaging?
Answered at 5:15 in Atlassian’s Head of Sales Compensation on the future of incentive design · The Sales Compensation Show
What is the maximum effective number of metrics and SPIFs in a sales compensation plan before sellers stop engaging?
When a demand generation plan had nine measures, each stakeholder decision made sense in isolation—marketing wanted certain outcomes, product wanted others, measurement required multiple metrics—but the result was that a single SDR was told to do nine things and would pick any two to focus on, losing control of the desired narrative. Adding too many SPIFs creates diminishing returns: sellers have constrained mindshare and cannot turn around without hitting a SPIF, so they tune out and pick two or three regardless of what is offered. The law of diminishing returns applies; having two to four compelling SPIFs works better than thirteen, because sellers cannot manually execute thirteen things in their compensation plan.
Full answer and detailsRead the whole answer, key facts and every other question from this episode
In short
When a demand generation plan had nine measures, each stakeholder decision made sense in isolation—marketing wanted certain outcomes, product wanted others, measurement required multiple metrics—but the result was that a single SDR was told to do nine thing…
Raji Narayanan, Head of Sales Compensation at Atlassian · Atlassian’s Head of Sales Compensation on the future of incentive design · The Sales Compensation Show · answer at 5:15
Quote to remember
“Less is more. You want it to be as simple as absolutely possible. Sometimes it's actually upstream problems that are not addressed.”
— Raji Narayanan
The full answer · about 3 min
When a demand generation plan had nine measures, each stakeholder decision made sense in isolation—marketing wanted certain outcomes, product wanted others, measurement required multiple metrics—but the result was that a single SDR was told to do nine things and would pick any two to focus on, losing control of the desired narrative. Adding too many SPIFs creates diminishing returns: sellers have constrained mindshare and cannot turn around without hitting a SPIF, so they tune out and pick two or three regardless of what is offered. The law of diminishing returns applies; having two to four compelling SPIFs works better than thirteen, because sellers cannot manually execute thirteen things in their compensation plan.
Key facts
- One demand generation plan had nine measures, creating complexity for a single SDR to execute
- Average AE makes significant cash flow from SPIFs, which represents a risk to quota attainment
- Six pages of crediting rules demonstrated organizational over-extension in plan design
- Dynamic pricing was implemented 10 years ago in previous organizations
- Most organizations spend six months doing annual planning and wait until year-end before revisiting compensation
People, companies and topics mentioned
More answers from this episode
- 3:00How should sales compensation plans balance strategy design with execution capability across systems and tools?
- 10:18How does Atlassian handle the tension between keeping compensation simple and managing underlying data complexity from multiple channels?
- 11:00Why is keeping payment terms and deal structure details out of the compensation plan critical for seller focus?
- 15:45What is the future direction of sales compensation design toward dynamic incentives rather than static annual plans?
- 20:00How can dynamic compensation plans prevent sellers from pattern-matching and gaming the system across quarters?