What happened when Janet McNamara asked her psychiatrist about a possible autism diagnosis?
Answered at 30:15 in 895: Label Maker! · This American Life
What happened when Janet McNamara asked her psychiatrist about a possible autism diagnosis?
When Janet McNamara raised the possibility of autism with her psychiatrist, he administered a test — then told her that people with Asperger's generally have above-average IQs, implying she was not smart enough to be mildly autistic. She decided to let the matter go. This happened in the 2010s, when adults seeking autism diagnoses was far less common than it is today.
A test administered, then a door quietly closed
McNamara did not dismiss the idea of autism out of hand. She brought it to her psychiatrist — a professional whose role was precisely to take such questions seriously. He did administer a test, which suggests the concern was treated as at least worth examining.
But the conclusion he offered was strikingly dismissive. He framed Asperger's as a condition associated with high intelligence, and the implication was clear: she did not meet that bar. The diagnosis was effectively ruled out through an IQ proxy, not through a thorough clinical process. This story is explored in depth in This American Life, episode 895, "Label Maker!"
The 2010s: a moment before adult autism diagnosis became normalized
McNamara's decision to drop the matter was also shaped by context. In the 2010s, the notion of an adult — especially an adult woman — pursuing an autism diagnosis was still unusual. The cultural and clinical landscape had not yet shifted to recognize how frequently autism in adults, and particularly in women, goes unidentified for decades.
Full answer and detailsRead the whole answer, key facts and every other question from this episode
In short
When Janet McNamara raised the possibility of autism with her psychiatrist, he administered a test — then told her that people with Asperger's generally have above-average IQs, implying she was not smart enough to be mildly autistic.
Ira Glass · 895: Label Maker! · This American Life · answer at 30:15
Key takeaways
- McNamara did not dismiss the idea of autism out of hand.
- But the conclusion he offered was strikingly dismissive.
- McNamara's decision to drop the matter was also shaped by context.
The full answer · about 1 min
When Janet McNamara raised the possibility of autism with her psychiatrist, he administered a test — then told her that people with Asperger's generally have above-average IQs, implying she was not smart enough to be mildly autistic. She decided to let the matter go. This happened in the 2010s, when adults seeking autism diagnoses was far less common than it is today.
A test administered, then a door quietly closed
McNamara did not dismiss the idea of autism out of hand. She brought it to her psychiatrist — a professional whose role was precisely to take such questions seriously. He did administer a test, which suggests the concern was treated as at least worth examining.
But the conclusion he offered was strikingly dismissive. He framed Asperger's as a condition associated with high intelligence, and the implication was clear: she did not meet that bar. The diagnosis was effectively ruled out through an IQ proxy, not through a thorough clinical process. This story is explored in depth in This American Life, episode 895, "Label Maker!"
The 2010s: a moment before adult autism diagnosis became normalized
McNamara's decision to drop the matter was also shaped by context. In the 2010s, the notion of an adult — especially an adult woman — pursuing an autism diagnosis was still unusual. The cultural and clinical landscape had not yet shifted to recognize how frequently autism in adults, and particularly in women, goes unidentified for decades.
More answers from this episode
- 5:42What is Temporary Protected Status (TPS) and how does it work in the US immigration system?
- 6:09How many Haitians were affected when the Trump administration ended TPS for Haiti?
- 6:30What happened to Marie, the Haitian CNA working at a Boston nursing home, when TPS ended?
- 12:59Why did Marie not tell her co-workers at the nursing home that she was on TPS and about to lose her job?
- 23:35What is the average tenure of a CNA (certified nursing assistant) in the United States?
- 27:28How did Janet McNamara first encounter the possibility that she might be autistic?