Our panel goes on shore leave with Maggie Smith
How does natural speech pattern affect a poet's reading of their own work?
Maggie Smith worries that her natural speech patterns—specifically her up-speak where she sounds like she's asking a question —become her version of the classic "poet voice" when she reads her own work. The very mannerism she uses in everyday conversation becomes an obstacle to authentic reading, blurring the line between her true voice and an affected performance.
The irony is sharp: Smith's concern isn't about adopting an artificial theatrical accent, but rather about how her organic way of speaking already carries a quality that sounds poetic in itself . Her up-speak—where statements climb in pitch at the end as if posed as questions—mirrors the vocal affectation many poets fall into when performing their work.
This creates a genuine tension for any poet reading aloud: distinguishing between authentic self-expression and the unconscious performance habits we all carry. Smith's honesty about this struggle reflects a wider truth about how writers navigate the gap between page and voice —and how hard it can be to recognize when our natural quirks already sound like the very thing we're trying to avoid.
Maggie Smith — Poet and Author. Smith is from Ohio, where her poem Good Bones became a viral sensation approximately a decade ago. This breakthrough led to her best-selling memoir You Could Make This Place Beautiful , followed by another New York Times bestseller, Dear Writer: Advice for the Creative Life . She continues to teach writing while living in her hometown near Columbus, Ohio.
What makes Smith's observation particularly valuable is that it reveals how even self-aware poets can't simply "switch off" their natural voice . The up-speak isn't a choice she makes at the podium—it's baked into her speech patterns. Recognizing it as an issue is one thing; fixing it in real time while performing is another. It points to the fundamental challenge of oral poetry: the voice we've developed over a lifetime of speaking will always color how we deliver words we've carefully chosen for the page.
This question of authenticity in performance is especially relevant for poets who rely on connecting directly with audiences through reading . Unlike novelists, who rarely perform their work, poets are expected to be the first interpreters of their own lines—and the audience expects that reading to feel intimate and genuine. When natural speech patterns inadvertently create distance or artifice, it undermines that intimacy.
The persistent echo of "poet voice"
Smith's particular challenge—the up-speak—is just one manifestation of a broader phenomenon. The "classic poet voice" that she worries about falling into has recognizable markers across the poetry world: exaggerated pacing, affected pronunciation, or dramatic pauses that signal "this is important" even when the poem itself asks for simplicity.
The fact that Smith is acutely aware of this pattern suggests she's actively listening to herself perform, trying to distinguish between her authentic self and the persona that emerges when she steps into the role of "poet reading her own work." This self-awareness is valuable, but it also places her in an uncomfortable position: knowing about the up-speak makes it harder to ignore, yet awareness alone doesn't eliminate the tendency.
Natural speech patterns—like up-speak—can inadvertently mimic the affected "poet voice" that readers try to avoid.
Self-awareness about these patterns doesn't automatically solve the problem; the voice remains embedded in how we speak.
The gap between written poetry and spoken performance reveals how our bodies and habits shape the meaning an audience receives.
Poets face a unique challenge: they are expected to be the first and most authentic interpreters of their own words, yet their natural voices may work against that expectation.
Smith is not comfortable improvising poems and requires ideas to arrive naturally rather than on command. When asked directly if she could compose one on the spot, she politely declined, asserting that while technically possible, she simply wouldn't do it.
What major literary figures and musicians come from Ohio?
Ohio has produced remarkable poets and musicians from Dayton , including Bob Pollard and Tim Deal, reflecting the state's deeply poetic cultural heritage. This creative tradition demonstrates that Ohio's artistic legacy extends far beyond its historical significance.
As Maggie Smith discusses in the episode , Ohio's artistic contributions are often overlooked despite the state's strong tradition of creative voices . The combination of poets and musicians emerging from cities like Dayton speaks to a vibrant cultural ecosystem that has shaped American music and literature.
Smith emphasizes that Ohio is incredibly poetic in its character and output. The state's creative legacy includes not just contemporary figures but a sustained tradition of artistic excellence that continues to influence American culture. This recognition reflects a deeper appreciation for regional artistic contributions beyond the usual cultural centers.
"People don't slide into my DMs for any kind of fun reason. It's always like, do you know a good lawyer? Have you been, like, how do you sleep at night? Does it get better?"
Maggie Smith — Poet and Author. Smith is from Ohio, and her poem Good Bones became a viral sensation about a decade ago, launching her into the spotlight. She has since published two New York Times bestsellers: You Could Make This Place Beautiful, a memoir exploring personal upheaval, and Dear Writer: Advice for the Creative Life, which offers guidance to aspiring writers. She continues to teach writing while living in her hometown near Columbus, Ohio.
The viral success of Smith's poetry demonstrates Ohio's cultural impact , even when that impact emerges unexpectedly. Her journey from Ohio poet to bestselling author shows how regional talent can resonate nationally and internationally, bringing attention to other Ohio-based artists like Pollard and Deal.
Musicians like Bob Pollard, known for his prolific output and influential indie rock work, and Tim Deal represent Ohio's contribution to American music history . These artists, rooted in Dayton's creative community, have influenced countless musicians and helped define genres that continue to shape contemporary music.
For anyone curious about Ohio's broader cultural contributions beyond what's covered here, there's much more context available in the full episode , where Smith reflects on her state's artistic identity and influence.
What is the core philosophy behind giving feedback to writers in the classroom?
Rather than offering direct criticism, ask questions that invite writers to reflect on their own work —prompts like "I'd like to know more about this" or "Can you tell me more about X?" shift the dynamic from judgment to curiosity. This approach, rooted in what Maggie Smith calls the "compliment sandwich," works not just in writing classrooms but in conversations with spouses, children, and colleagues.
Smith's philosophy centers on becoming a questioner rather than a critic. Instead of telling a student what's wrong, she guides them toward discovering the answer themselves through genuine inquiry. This method respects the writer's voice and agency while still offering meaningful feedback.
The strength of questioning lies in its versatility. As Smith explains in her appearance on Wait Wait... Don't Tell Me! , the same technique applies across contexts—whether teaching students, parenting, or collaborating with colleagues. Questions create space for dialogue rather than defensiveness.
A gentle alternative to direct critique
The compliment sandwich approach softens delivery, but Smith goes further: she replaces critique altogether with curiosity. A writer who hears "I'd like to know more about this" doesn't feel attacked; instead, they feel invited to deepen their thinking . The question assumes good intent and incomplete development, not failure.
This stance is particularly powerful in creative work, where emotional investment runs high. By asking rather than telling, Smith preserves the relationship between teacher and student while still moving the work forward. The writer often discovers their own solutions—and those solutions feel like their own because they are.
Smith's method has proven effective enough that she's developed it into a full guide for writers called Dear Writer: Advice for the Creative Life , her second New York Times bestseller, which extends this philosophy beyond the classroom.
"I would like to know more about this. Can you tell me more about X?"
Maggie Smith — Poet and author from Ohio. Her viral poem "Good Bones" launched her career a decade ago, leading to the bestselling memoir You Could Make This Place Beautiful . She continues to teach writing while based near Columbus, Ohio, and has authored Dear Writer: Advice for the Creative Life , a second bestseller that distills her classroom philosophy into actionable guidance for writers at all stages.
What makes this approach resonate beyond the page is its humanity. As Smith discusses in the episode , she applies these same principles when navigating difficult personal exchanges—moments that reveal how feedback philosophy shapes everyday life. This consistency suggests that questioning, at its core, is less a teaching technique and more a stance toward other people's growth.
Questions beat criticism: "I'd like to know more" invites reflection without judgment.
The compliment sandwich softens delivery, but genuine curiosity eliminates defensiveness entirely.
This method transfers across relationships—classrooms, families, and professional teams all benefit.
Writers guided by questions often find their own solutions, creating ownership of the revision.
What role does a poet take on when readers reach out through social media about personal crises?
Maggie Smith has become what she calls a "divorce whisperer," fielding direct messages from readers experiencing personal crises who ask her for everything from lawyer recommendations to reassurance about whether life improves. Rather than step back from this unexpected pastoral role, Smith engages genuinely with people seeking guidance from someone who has lived through similar struggles.
The shift from poet to informal counselor happened organically. After her poem Good Bones went viral about a decade ago, Smith found herself at the center of a deeply personal phenomenon. Readers connected with her vulnerability and began reaching out with their own pain. As Smith explains in her appearance on the show , the messages rarely come for lighthearted reasons—they arrive when someone is in genuine distress.
What makes this role distinct is Smith's recognition that people don't turn to her as a celebrity or advice columnist, but as a fellow traveler who has publicly documented her own journey through difficulty. She has written extensively about her experiences in her best-selling memoir You Could Make This Place Beautiful, and later in Dear Writer: Advice for the Creative Life, establishing herself as someone willing to speak candidly about struggle.
The kinds of questions Smith receives vary widely—practical concerns like finding legal representation mix with existential ones about resilience and hope. In the podcast, Smith explores how this dynamic has transformed her relationship with her own writing , turning her platform into something she never anticipated but has come to understand as part of her work as a writer and teacher living in her native Ohio.
"People don't slide into my DMs for any kind of fun reason. It's always like, do you know a good lawyer? Have you been, like, how do you sleep at night? Does it get better?"
Maggie Smith — Poet and Author. Smith is from Ohio, best known for her viral poem Good Bones, which launched her to broader recognition about a decade ago. She is the author of the New York Times bestsellers You Could Make This Place Beautiful and Dear Writer: Advice for the Creative Life, and continues to teach writing while based in her hometown near Columbus.
The full conversation delves deeper into how Smith manages the emotional labor of this unexpected role , and what it means for a writer to hold space for others' pain while continuing to create her own work.
Smith has become an informal counselor to readers experiencing personal crises through social media direct messages.
She receives practical requests (lawyer recommendations) alongside deeper existential questions about recovery and resilience.
People reach out to her specifically because she has publicly shared her own struggles through her writing and memoirs.
This role, though unexpected, has become part of Smith's broader identity as a writer, teacher, and public figure.
We fold our phones and get roasted by Leslie Jones
What are the most shocking design failures found in short-term rental properties?
Renters and hosts of short-term properties have committed some genuinely baffling design crimes. Bathroom carpet tops the list—an utterly impractical and unhygienic choice that Leslie Jones called "against humanity." Beyond that, unexpected architectural nightmares emerge: beehives built directly into master bedroom walls (and owners claiming they were always there), and layouts so nonsensical they defy any logical aesthetic or functional purpose.
The sheer audacity of these choices becomes clear when you consider their practical impact. A bathroom is one of the wettest rooms in any property, making carpet an almost comically poor material choice that invites mold, odor, and structural damage. Yet hosts continue to make it, apparently without second-guessing the decision.
As Leslie Jones details in her appearances on the podcast , these failures extend beyond single bad calls. Some properties suffer from what can only be described as layout nonsense—configurations so poorly thought-out that they undermine basic living comfort and visual coherence. The pattern suggests that many short-term rental owners are either not checking their properties thoroughly or are making decisions in a vacuum, divorced from any real-world usability standards.
"I lovingly tell you that their rental sucks."
Leslie Jones — Stand-up Comedian and Host of Roast My Rental on HGTV. Jones transitioned from college basketball at Colorado State University to stand-up comedy, winning a campus comedy competition before being personally recommended to Saturday Night Live by Chris Rock. She now hosts a show dedicated to critiquing short-term rental design failures.
What makes these failures so striking is their permanence and visibility. Unlike a furniture choice or paint color that can be changed quickly, these structural and layout decisions are baked into the rental's core identity—and they're the first thing guests encounter. A beehive in the master bedroom or bathroom carpet sends an immediate signal about how much thought (or how little) went into the space.
The full episode of Wait Wait... Don't Tell Me! reveals even more of the absurd design choices Leslie Jones has uncovered, offering a catalog of what not to do if you're renting out a property to actual human beings.
Carpet in bathrooms is an actively harmful design choice that invites moisture, mold, and decay.
Structural oddities like beehives in bedrooms are sometimes defended by owners as pre-existing, dodging accountability.
Illogical room layouts and spatial arrangements suggest many hosts have not lived in or fully considered their own rental properties.
These failures are immediately visible to guests and set the tone for the entire rental experience.
The Wait Wait 2026 summer spectacular, part 1!
Did Lilly King engage in trash talk with competitors before races?
King confirmed she did talk trash to opponents before races, noting that her competitors did not appreciate it. She acknowledged that in one Olympic final,…
How does Lilly King describe the mental pressure of competing at Olympic trials in swimming?
Olympic trials in swimming are unlike any other competition: typically 100 to 150 athletes enter a single event, but only two will make the Olympic team. Lilly King says the mindset walking into the final is stark and unambiguous — "don't mess up." She confirmed she still got nervous, even when she expected to win.
100 to 150 swimmers. Two spots. One clear directive.
What makes Olympic trials structurally different from a regular championship meet is its binary outcome. There is no bronze medal, no consolation. King made this plain: the entire purpose of the meet is to finish in the top two in your event. Everyone else goes home.
With a field of 100 to 150 competitors in a single event, the margin for error is essentially zero. That arithmetic alone reshapes how a swimmer approaches race day — not as a performance to optimize, but as a mistake to avoid. As discussed in Wait Wait... Don't Tell Me! , King distilled that pressure into three words.
Expecting to win — and still getting nervous
King's candor on this point is striking. She is among the most decorated American swimmers of her generation, and she goes into Olympic trials expecting to win. That expectation does not insulate her from nerves. She confirmed openly that she does get nervous — a detail that cuts against the public image of elite athletes as impassive competitors immune to pressure.
The distinction she drew is important: confidence and anxiety are not mutually exclusive at that level. Expecting to win and fearing to lose are two states that coexist in the same race. Lilly King spoke about this with a directness that made the moment land, as captured in this episode of the podcast .
"As somebody with a mild case of cerebral palsy, the marching with the tuba that I selected as my instrument was a horrendous idea."
Jason Benetti — Play-by-play announcer, Sunday Night Baseball (NBC) and former voice of the Detroit Tigers and Chicago White Sox. Benetti grew up in Chicago and started his broadcasting career at Syracuse University's student radio station in 2003. His first on-air lead-in was the NPR News with Carl Castle. His high school band director at Homewood Flossmoor High School redirected him from the tuba to a microphone — where he announced the band's set — after his cerebral palsy made marching impractical. That accidental pivot toward a microphone foreshadowed a career that eventually took him to NBC's Sunday Night Baseball in 2026. He shared this origin story on Wait Wait... Don't Tell Me!
The episode features several guests speaking with remarkable openness about performance, pressure, and identity — a tone consistent across the hour. King's segment on Olympic trials sits alongside Benetti's reflections on his own unlikely path to the broadcast booth, both stories anchored in the gap between expectation and reality. The full conversation is available on Wait Wait... Don't Tell Me!
How did Olympic swimmer Lilly King get proposed to by her husband?
Lilly King was proposed to on the pool deck at Olympic trials, right after finishing a race. Her husband, a former swim team member, managed to get onto the…
Who is Michael Threatt and what is his connection to Reading Rainbow?
Michael Threatt is a librarian who was named the new host of Reading Rainbow from PBS. He grew up being homeschooled and became a devoted fan of the…
Why did Jason Benetti leave the Chicago White Sox broadcast booth?
Benetti left the White Sox and joined the Detroit Tigers, and the White Sox subsequently recorded the worst record in the modern era for a baseball team.…
What is the most unusual sporting event Jason Benetti ever had to broadcast?
Benetti was called to do play-by-play and post-production from a studio for the National Electrician's Championships. His analyst was Scott Karen, the…
What was Jason Benetti's connection to NPR early in his broadcasting career?
The student radio station at Syracuse University, where famous sportscasters like Bob Costas, Marv Albert, and Sean McDonough came through, was an NPR…
How did Jason Benetti first get behind a microphone as a broadcaster?
Jason Benetti has a mild case of cerebral palsy, which made marching in the band impractical. After failing as drum major and then marching in place on the…