What is the role of junior employees and 'jilted' insiders in uncovering major business stories?
Answered at 24:00 in The Insane Productivity of Andrew Ross Sorkin · ACQ2 by Acquired
What is the role of junior employees and 'jilted' insiders in uncovering major business stories?
The best stories rarely come from senior executives protecting their interests. Instead, they originate from people who have lost something and have no remaining stake in the game —what Andrew Sorkin calls the "jilted somebody." These are junior employees or insiders who lost an auction, were passed over for a major client or deal, or saw years of work stolen by a competitor. With nothing left to protect, they become willing sources.
Sorkin identifies a clear pattern in investigative reporting: great stories begin at very junior levels, not in corner offices. A junior banker who spent months cultivating a client relationship only to watch Goldman Sachs win the account feels betrayed. A business development executive who lost a critical merger to a rival has motive to talk. These individuals are far more inclined to leak information or provide insights to reporters than someone still playing the game and worried about their career.
The mechanism is psychological. When someone has exhausted their options within the system—when they have been rejected, overlooked, or beaten—the only remaining source of control is the ability to upset the situation. For a reporter, this makes them ideal sources. As Sorkin explains in the episode, identifying who has lost something is as important as identifying who has won.
"I think it's important to understand what their motivation is. But ultimately, as long as I can confirm the information typically from two, three, four different sources, or I can get documentation of the issue, I try not to worry too much about what their ultimate incentives are."
Andrew Sorkin — Anchor, CNBC Squawk Box, and Founder of DealBook. Sorkin joined the New York Times at age 18 in 1995 and founded DealBook in 2001 as an email newsletter covering mergers and acquisitions. Over 25 years, he has grown it to over one million subscribers while co-creating the television series Billions and authoring two major books: Too Big to Fail and 1929.
This approach to source motivation reflects a deeper truth about investigative journalism: the story's value depends not on a source's purity, but on verification. A motivated source is not a disqualified source. What matters is confirmation from multiple independent sources or hard documentation, as Sorkin emphasizes. Once information is verified through these channels, the source's original motive becomes secondary.
Full answer and detailsRead the whole answer, key facts and every other question from this episode
In short
The best stories rarely come from senior executives protecting their interests.
Andrew Sorkin · The Insane Productivity of Andrew Ross Sorkin · ACQ2 by Acquired · answer at 24:00
Key takeaways
- Sorkin identifies a clear pattern in investigative reporting: great stories begin at very junior levels, not in corner offices.
- I think it's important to understand what their motivation is.
- Andrew Sorkin — Anchor, CNBC Squawk Box, and Founder of DealBook.
- This approach to source motivation reflects a deeper truth about investigative journalism: the story's value depends not on a source's purity, but on verification.
The full answer · about 4 min
The best stories rarely come from senior executives protecting their interests. Instead, they originate from people who have lost something and have no remaining stake in the game —what Andrew Sorkin calls the "jilted somebody." These are junior employees or insiders who lost an auction, were passed over for a major client or deal, or saw years of work stolen by a competitor. With nothing left to protect, they become willing sources.
Sorkin identifies a clear pattern in investigative reporting: great stories begin at very junior levels, not in corner offices. A junior banker who spent months cultivating a client relationship only to watch Goldman Sachs win the account feels betrayed. A business development executive who lost a critical merger to a rival has motive to talk. These individuals are far more inclined to leak information or provide insights to reporters than someone still playing the game and worried about their career.
The mechanism is psychological. When someone has exhausted their options within the system—when they have been rejected, overlooked, or beaten—the only remaining source of control is the ability to upset the situation. For a reporter, this makes them ideal sources. As Sorkin explains in the episode, identifying who has lost something is as important as identifying who has won.
"I think it's important to understand what their motivation is. But ultimately, as long as I can confirm the information typically from two, three, four different sources, or I can get documentation of the issue, I try not to worry too much about what their ultimate incentives are."
Andrew Sorkin — Anchor, CNBC Squawk Box, and Founder of DealBook. Sorkin joined the New York Times at age 18 in 1995 and founded DealBook in 2001 as an email newsletter covering mergers and acquisitions. Over 25 years, he has grown it to over one million subscribers while co-creating the television series Billions and authoring two major books: Too Big to Fail and 1929.
This approach to source motivation reflects a deeper truth about investigative journalism: the story's value depends not on a source's purity, but on verification. A motivated source is not a disqualified source. What matters is confirmation from multiple independent sources or hard documentation, as Sorkin emphasizes. Once information is verified through these channels, the source's original motive becomes secondary.
More answers from this episode
- 3:30How does a media professional manage multiple demanding roles simultaneously across television, newsletters, and books?
- 9:00What was Andrew Ross Sorkin's business venture before joining the New York Times full-time?
- 12:00How did Andrew Ross Sorkin's first assignment at the New York Times happen?
- 14:06How did a reporter launch a daily email newsletter in 2001, over 15 years before Substack emerged?
- 18:06What was the first advertiser for DealBook when it launched?
- 18:06What was the initial market size expectation for DealBook compared to its actual growth?
- 21:00How should journalists approach sources who have mixed or ulterior motives for sharing information?