Listenly

How should journalists approach sources who have mixed or ulterior motives for sharing information?

Answered at 21:00 in The Insane Productivity of Andrew Ross Sorkin · ACQ2 by Acquired

— questions searchable right now

How should journalists approach sources who have mixed or ulterior motives for sharing information?

Accept that every source has some self-interested motivation for talking, and don't waste energy worrying about what it is. Instead, focus on verification: confirm the information from two, three, or four independent sources, or obtain hard documentation. If the facts check out, the motive no longer matters—whether that source is a board member trying to derail a deal, a banker seeking revenge against a competitor, or anyone else with an axe to grind.

As Andrew Sorkin explains in this episode, journalism often happens on the back of sources with the worst possible motives. The insight isn't naive—it's pragmatic. Some of the best investigative stories come from people trying to sabotage someone else or advance their own interests, not from truth-seekers motivated by the public good.

The key is shifting the burden of proof. Don't authenticate the source; authenticate the story. A board member leaking details about a merger to stop it? That leak might be pure sabotage—but if you can cross-check those details with another source, with SEC filings, with email records, the source's toxicity becomes irrelevant. The documentation is what counts.

"I think it's important to understand what their motivation is. But ultimately, as long as I can confirm the information typically from two, three, four different sources, or I can get documentation of the issue, I try not to worry too much about what their ultimate incentives are."

Andrew Sorkin — Anchor, CNBC Squawk Box, and Founder of DealBook. Sorkin joined the New York Times at age 18 in 1995 and founded DealBook in 2001, growing it to over one million subscribers. He is also the co-creator of the television series Billions and author of Too Big to Fail and 1929.

This approach reflects decades of reporting on Wall Street and corporate deals. Throughout his career at the New York Times and DealBook, Sorkin has learned that the worst-intentioned sources often possess the most valuable information—they have skin in the game, access, and incentive to talk. The journalist's job isn't moral gatekeeping; it's verification.

Andrew Sorkin on ACQ2 by AcquiredAll answers from this podcast →
Full answer and detailsRead the whole answer, key facts and every other question from this episode

In short

Accept that every source has some self-interested motivation for talking, and don't waste energy worrying about what it is.

Andrew Sorkin · The Insane Productivity of Andrew Ross Sorkin · ACQ2 by Acquired · answer at 21:00

Key takeaways

  • Instead, focus on verification: confirm the information from two, three, or four independent sources, or obtain hard documentation.
  • As Andrew Sorkin explains in this episode, journalism often happens on the back of sources with the worst possible motives.
  • The key is shifting the burden of proof.
  • I think it's important to understand what their motivation is.
  • Andrew Sorkin — Anchor, CNBC Squawk Box, and Founder of DealBook.

The full answer · about 5 min

Accept that every source has some self-interested motivation for talking, and don't waste energy worrying about what it is. Instead, focus on verification: confirm the information from two, three, or four independent sources, or obtain hard documentation. If the facts check out, the motive no longer matters—whether that source is a board member trying to derail a deal, a banker seeking revenge against a competitor, or anyone else with an axe to grind.

As Andrew Sorkin explains in this episode, journalism often happens on the back of sources with the worst possible motives. The insight isn't naive—it's pragmatic. Some of the best investigative stories come from people trying to sabotage someone else or advance their own interests, not from truth-seekers motivated by the public good.

The key is shifting the burden of proof. Don't authenticate the source; authenticate the story. A board member leaking details about a merger to stop it? That leak might be pure sabotage—but if you can cross-check those details with another source, with SEC filings, with email records, the source's toxicity becomes irrelevant. The documentation is what counts.

"I think it's important to understand what their motivation is. But ultimately, as long as I can confirm the information typically from two, three, four different sources, or I can get documentation of the issue, I try not to worry too much about what their ultimate incentives are."

Andrew Sorkin — Anchor, CNBC Squawk Box, and Founder of DealBook. Sorkin joined the New York Times at age 18 in 1995 and founded DealBook in 2001, growing it to over one million subscribers. He is also the co-creator of the television series Billions and author of Too Big to Fail and 1929.

This approach reflects decades of reporting on Wall Street and corporate deals. Throughout his career at the New York Times and DealBook, Sorkin has learned that the worst-intentioned sources often possess the most valuable information—they have skin in the game, access, and incentive to talk. The journalist's job isn't moral gatekeeping; it's verification.

More answers from this episode

 ·  All answers from ACQ2 by Acquired →
—
—
0:00
0:00