What is the core difference between managing under pressure and leading under pressure in project management?
Answered at 17:17 in The Human Skills That Make or Break a Project Manager | Ep. 13 · Beyond The Plan
What is the core difference between managing under pressure and leading under pressure in project management?
Managing under pressure means you are handling your own performance adequately, but leading under pressure means you are actively helping your team navigate difficult phases as well. As a project manager, staying calm and providing clarity and direction to your team remains essential even when facing severe financial, time, personnel, or third-party pressures.
The distinction matters because many project managers conflate coping with crisis with actually leading their team through it. You might be meeting your own deadlines and maintaining your composure, yet if your team is confused, demoralised, or left without clear direction, you're only managing yourself—not leading.
Nick Jagger, whose 45 years of project management experience spans major infrastructure projects including work as a risk manager on the $8 billion Northwest Ruralink (later Sydney Metro), emphasises that this shift from managing to leading is fundamental. The technical aspects of the role—schedules, budgets, scope—pale in comparison to how you hold the space for your people during crisis.
Real leadership under pressure involves communicating with transparency. Your team needs to understand what constraints exist, what options remain on the table, and what you expect from them. Without that clarity, pressure cascades downward as anxiety rather than focus.
"It is not necessarily what the project manager knows that makes the difference. It is how they can work with the team."
Nick Jagger — Technical Director of Project Management, Elemental Projects. A project management veteran with 45 years of experience, Jagger studied a Masters of Project Management at UTS and worked on major infrastructure projects including the Northwest Ruralink as a risk manager. After approximately 10 years with risk management firm ACOM, he moved to smaller consultancy Ontwit focusing on social infrastructure, then to Mark McDonald as technical director, before joining Elemental Projects 18 months ago.
Full answer and detailsRead the whole answer, key facts and every other question from this episode
In short
Managing under pressure means you are handling your own performance adequately, but leading under pressure means you are actively helping your team navigate difficult phases as well.
Nick Jagger · The Human Skills That Make or Break a Project Manager | Ep. 13 · Beyond The Plan · answer at 17:17
Key takeaways
- As a project manager, staying calm and providing clarity and direction to your team remains essential even when facing severe financial, time, personnel, or third-party pressures.
- The distinction matters because many project managers conflate coping with crisis with actually leading their team through it.
- Nick Jagger, whose 45 years of project management experience spans major infrastructure projects including work as a risk manager on the $8 billion Northwest Ruralink (later Sydney Metro), emphasises that this shift from managing to leading is fundamental.
- Real leadership under pressure involves communicating with transparency.
- Nick Jagger — Technical Director of Project Management, Elemental Projects.
Quote to remember
“It is not necessarily what the project manager knows that makes the difference. It is how they can work with the team.”
— Nick Jagger
The full answer · about 1 min
Managing under pressure means you are handling your own performance adequately, but leading under pressure means you are actively helping your team navigate difficult phases as well. As a project manager, staying calm and providing clarity and direction to your team remains essential even when facing severe financial, time, personnel, or third-party pressures.
The distinction matters because many project managers conflate coping with crisis with actually leading their team through it. You might be meeting your own deadlines and maintaining your composure, yet if your team is confused, demoralised, or left without clear direction, you're only managing yourself—not leading.
Nick Jagger, whose 45 years of project management experience spans major infrastructure projects including work as a risk manager on the $8 billion Northwest Ruralink (later Sydney Metro), emphasises that this shift from managing to leading is fundamental. The technical aspects of the role—schedules, budgets, scope—pale in comparison to how you hold the space for your people during crisis.
Real leadership under pressure involves communicating with transparency. Your team needs to understand what constraints exist, what options remain on the table, and what you expect from them. Without that clarity, pressure cascades downward as anxiety rather than focus.
"It is not necessarily what the project manager knows that makes the difference. It is how they can work with the team."
Nick Jagger — Technical Director of Project Management, Elemental Projects. A project management veteran with 45 years of experience, Jagger studied a Masters of Project Management at UTS and worked on major infrastructure projects including the Northwest Ruralink as a risk manager. After approximately 10 years with risk management firm ACOM, he moved to smaller consultancy Ontwit focusing on social infrastructure, then to Mark McDonald as technical director, before joining Elemental Projects 18 months ago.
More answers from this episode
- 6:09Why is technical skill alone insufficient to make an effective project manager?
- 8:00How has the role of project manager evolved from the 1950s to today?
- 10:22Should capability or experience be the primary criterion for assessing whether someone can be an effective project manager?
- 11:20What is the difference between knowledge and skills in project management, and why does this distinction matter?
- 13:13What role does VUCA play in explaining why soft skills now matter more than technical expertise in projects?
- 14:53How can project managers help their teams navigate problems and uncertainty without causing panic or denial?
- 21:03How should project managers approach problem-solving when issues arise under stress rather than reacting immediately?