Should capability or experience be the primary criterion for assessing whether someone can be an effective project manager?
Answered at 10:22 in The Human Skills That Make or Break a Project Manager | Ep. 13 · Beyond The Plan
Should capability or experience be the primary criterion for assessing whether someone can be an effective project manager?
Experience is not the best indicator of successful projects. A highly competent project manager with strong capability could work on any project, whereas experience is project-specific. While specialized technical knowledge may be needed for critical projects like nuclear power plants, outside of such specialties, capability in project management should transfer across infrastructure, banking, communications, and other fields. Capability should be prioritized over years of experience.
Full answer and detailsRead the whole answer, key facts and every other question from this episode
In short
Experience is not the best indicator of successful projects.
Nick Jagger · The Human Skills That Make or Break a Project Manager | Ep. 13 · Beyond The Plan · answer at 10:22
Key takeaways
- Experience is not the best indicator of successful projects.
The full answer · about 3 min
Experience is not the best indicator of successful projects. A highly competent project manager with strong capability could work on any project, whereas experience is project-specific. While specialized technical knowledge may be needed for critical projects like nuclear power plants, outside of such specialties, capability in project management should transfer across infrastructure, banking, communications, and other fields. Capability should be prioritized over years of experience.
More answers from this episode
- 6:09Why is technical skill alone insufficient to make an effective project manager?
- 8:00How has the role of project manager evolved from the 1950s to today?
- 11:20What is the difference between knowledge and skills in project management, and why does this distinction matter?
- 13:13What role does VUCA play in explaining why soft skills now matter more than technical expertise in projects?
- 14:53How can project managers help their teams navigate problems and uncertainty without causing panic or denial?
- 17:17What is the core difference between managing under pressure and leading under pressure in project management?
- 21:03How should project managers approach problem-solving when issues arise under stress rather than reacting immediately?