Why do most project failures occur after a contract is signed?
Answered at 0:39 in How Collaborative Working Saves Projects | Project Management | Ep. 15 · Beyond The Plan
Why do most project failures occur after a contract is signed?
Project failures rarely stem from budget, timeline, or scope alone—they emerge from teams' inability to act on problems they already know how to solve due to contractual boundaries, organisational silos, lack of authority, or a priority on commercial outcomes over actual project success. A signed contract, no matter how detailed, cannot by itself mobilise individuals to work effectively together within a truly collaborative framework.
The Hidden Problem: Contracts Don't Guarantee Collaboration
Most project managers assume a signed contract marks the beginning of execution. In reality, it often marks the moment when structural barriers emerge that prevent teams from acting. Brett Ackroyd, a commercial lawyer with 26 years of experience on defence and government mega-projects, explains that contractual language addresses only one dimension of project delivery—the legal one.
The real failure mechanism is more subtle. Teams possess the knowledge and capability to solve problems, but organisational boundaries, lack of cross-functional authority, and competing commercial incentives create paralysis. A developer knows how to fix a design flaw; a supply chain manager sees a cost-saving opportunity; a partner identifies a risk—yet none act, because the contract, the hierarchy, or the fear of liability stops them first.
As Ackroyd discusses in the podcast, this isn't a training or communication problem. It's a systemic one embedded in how organisations structure relationships and incentives around projects. When people prioritise protecting their contractual position over advancing the collective outcome, the project—not the contract—suffers the consequences.
Values and Behaviours: The Foundation Contracts Miss
Full answer and detailsRead the whole answer, key facts and every other question from this episode
In short
Project failures rarely stem from budget, timeline, or scope alone—they emerge from teams' inability to act on problems they already know how to solve due to contractual boundaries, organisational silos, lack of authority, or a priority on commercial outcom…
Ali Farhoodi · How Collaborative Working Saves Projects | Project Management | Ep. 15 · Beyond The Plan · answer at 0:39
Key takeaways
- A signed contract, no matter how detailed, cannot by itself mobilise individuals to work effectively together within a truly collaborative framework.
- Most project managers assume a signed contract marks the beginning of execution.
- The real failure mechanism is more subtle.
- As Ackroyd discusses in the podcast, this isn't a training or communication problem.
The full answer · about 1 min
Project failures rarely stem from budget, timeline, or scope alone—they emerge from teams' inability to act on problems they already know how to solve due to contractual boundaries, organisational silos, lack of authority, or a priority on commercial outcomes over actual project success. A signed contract, no matter how detailed, cannot by itself mobilise individuals to work effectively together within a truly collaborative framework.
The Hidden Problem: Contracts Don't Guarantee Collaboration
Most project managers assume a signed contract marks the beginning of execution. In reality, it often marks the moment when structural barriers emerge that prevent teams from acting. Brett Ackroyd, a commercial lawyer with 26 years of experience on defence and government mega-projects, explains that contractual language addresses only one dimension of project delivery—the legal one.
The real failure mechanism is more subtle. Teams possess the knowledge and capability to solve problems, but organisational boundaries, lack of cross-functional authority, and competing commercial incentives create paralysis. A developer knows how to fix a design flaw; a supply chain manager sees a cost-saving opportunity; a partner identifies a risk—yet none act, because the contract, the hierarchy, or the fear of liability stops them first.
As Ackroyd discusses in the podcast, this isn't a training or communication problem. It's a systemic one embedded in how organisations structure relationships and incentives around projects. When people prioritise protecting their contractual position over advancing the collective outcome, the project—not the contract—suffers the consequences.
Values and Behaviours: The Foundation Contracts Miss
More answers from this episode
- 8:10How should business relationship management be structured in major projects?
- 11:00Why must collaborative working culture be designed to be enduring beyond individual relationships?
- 23:43What happens when teams take a claims-focused approach instead of collaborative problem-solving?
- 30:45How can predictable relationship management improve project productivity?