What happens when teams take a claims-focused approach instead of collaborative problem-solving?
Answered at 23:43 in How Collaborative Working Saves Projects | Project Management | Ep. 15 · Beyond The Plan
What happens when teams take a claims-focused approach instead of collaborative problem-solving?
Australia spends more of its project budget on claims than any other Western nation, a direct result of teams prioritizing contractual leverage over collaborative problem-solving. When parties adopt a claims-focused mindset, they hold back discovered problems for future negotiation, eroding trust and making everyone defensive about contractual certainty rather than focused on achieving the shared project objective.
The Cost of Holding Back Information
In a claims-focused culture, teams treat problems as negotiating ammunition rather than shared challenges to solve together. When someone discovers an issue, instead of raising it immediately for the team's benefit, they file it away as a potential claim. This defensive posture transforms relationships from collaborative to adversarial, where each party views the other as a future opponent rather than a partner in delivery.
As Brett Ackroyd explains in the episode, this mindset makes people reluctant to expose vulnerabilities or admit they need help. Problems that could be solved quickly and cheaply spiral into expensive disputes because they were never raised in real time. The financial impact compounds across years of project execution.
The Trust Erosion Cycle
Trust is fragile in a claims-focused environment. Once teams sense that others are withholding information or waiting for an opportunity to lodge a claim, defensive behaviour spreads across the entire organisation. People become focused on protecting their contractual position rather than solving problems, which directly undermines project performance and delivery timelines.
Full answer and detailsRead the whole answer, key facts and every other question from this episode
In short
Australia spends more of its project budget on claims than any other Western nation, a direct result of teams prioritizing contractual leverage over collaborative problem-solving.
Ali Farhoodi · How Collaborative Working Saves Projects | Project Management | Ep. 15 · Beyond The Plan · answer at 23:43
Key takeaways
- When parties adopt a claims-focused mindset, they hold back discovered problems for future negotiation, eroding trust and making everyone defensive about contractual certainty rather than focused on achieving the shared project objective.
- In a claims-focused culture, teams treat problems as negotiating ammunition rather than shared challenges to solve together.
- As Brett Ackroyd explains in the episode, this mindset makes people reluctant to expose vulnerabilities or admit they need help.
- Trust is fragile in a claims-focused environment.
The full answer · about 1 min
Australia spends more of its project budget on claims than any other Western nation, a direct result of teams prioritizing contractual leverage over collaborative problem-solving. When parties adopt a claims-focused mindset, they hold back discovered problems for future negotiation, eroding trust and making everyone defensive about contractual certainty rather than focused on achieving the shared project objective.
The Cost of Holding Back Information
In a claims-focused culture, teams treat problems as negotiating ammunition rather than shared challenges to solve together. When someone discovers an issue, instead of raising it immediately for the team's benefit, they file it away as a potential claim. This defensive posture transforms relationships from collaborative to adversarial, where each party views the other as a future opponent rather than a partner in delivery.
As Brett Ackroyd explains in the episode, this mindset makes people reluctant to expose vulnerabilities or admit they need help. Problems that could be solved quickly and cheaply spiral into expensive disputes because they were never raised in real time. The financial impact compounds across years of project execution.
The Trust Erosion Cycle
Trust is fragile in a claims-focused environment. Once teams sense that others are withholding information or waiting for an opportunity to lodge a claim, defensive behaviour spreads across the entire organisation. People become focused on protecting their contractual position rather than solving problems, which directly undermines project performance and delivery timelines.
More answers from this episode
- 0:39Why do most project failures occur after a contract is signed?
- 8:10How should business relationship management be structured in major projects?
- 11:00Why must collaborative working culture be designed to be enduring beyond individual relationships?
- 30:45How can predictable relationship management improve project productivity?