Why did New Mexico's 2007 ban on construction retentions fail and what workarounds did contractors use?
Answered at 21:30 in 197: Rudi Klein on payment reform · Re:Construction
Why did New Mexico's 2007 ban on construction retentions fail and what workarounds did contractors use?
The New Mexico legislation banning retentions in 2007 became ineffective because contractors found ways around it. Rather than explicitly taking retentions, they withheld sums of money earlier in the payment process by not paying full amounts, creating hidden retentions. Alternatively, they renamed retentions as bonuses—paying a bonus only on completion once satisfied with the work, which legally circumvents the ban.
Full answer and detailsRead the whole answer, key facts and every other question from this episode
In short
The New Mexico legislation banning retentions in 2007 became ineffective because contractors found ways around it.
Rudi Klein, Barrister and Director at Klein Legal · 197: Rudi Klein on payment reform · Re:Construction · answer at 21:30
Key takeaways
- The New Mexico legislation banning retentions in 2007 became ineffective because contractors found ways around it.
Quote to remember
“You can't collaborate with anybody who's actually not paying you. So any reform or transformation of the industry must require this whole subject of payment to be addressed.”
— Rudi Klein
The full answer · about 1 min
The New Mexico legislation banning retentions in 2007 became ineffective because contractors found ways around it. Rather than explicitly taking retentions, they withheld sums of money earlier in the payment process by not paying full amounts, creating hidden retentions. Alternatively, they renamed retentions as bonuses—paying a bonus only on completion once satisfied with the work, which legally circumvents the ban.
Key facts
- National Highways processes 20 to 25 billion pounds worth of work through project bank accounts
- National Highways pays contractors within 18 days via project bank accounts
- Government consultation on payment reform launched July 2024, closed October 2024
- Scotland and Wales mandate project bank accounts for projects valued at £2 million and above
- Payment periods proposed capped at 60 days maximum
People, companies and topics mentioned
More answers from this episode
- 3:01What are the government's proposed payment reforms for UK construction and what is the retention deposit scheme consultation?
- 11:00What is a project bank account and how does it protect construction supply chains from contractor insolvency?
- 13:50What happened to ISG and its supply chain in relation to the Ministry of Justice contracts?
- 25:40How much value has National Highways processed through project bank accounts and what payment speed have they achieved?
- 28:20What threshold does Scotland and Wales use for mandatory project bank accounts in construction?