How should business owners approach using AI-generated legal content when facing litigation?
Answered at 14:00 in Helping Business Owners Navigate Legal Challenges with Confidence (Brian Calhoun (Managing Partner) & Blake Brownshadel (Partner), Calhoun Bhella LLP) · The Think Small Podcast
How should business owners approach using AI-generated legal content when facing litigation?
Business owners should avoid relying on AI-generated content like ChatGPT for litigation matters because prompts entered into OpenAI are discoverable in court and receive no protection under attorney-client privilege or work product doctrine. Sending AI-generated responses to your attorney creates false expectations and clutters the legal strategy with unreliable information courts increasingly treat as ordinary business records, not privileged communications.
The core problem lies in how legal discovery works. When litigation begins, as Brian Calhoun explains in this episode, any written communication between you and your attorney—or between you and third parties about your legal situation—becomes fair game for opposing counsel to request. If you generated that content using a public AI service like ChatGPT, that entire chain of prompts and responses can be subpoenaed and introduced as evidence. Courts are increasingly ruling that searches and prompts using open AI platforms lack the confidentiality protection that shields genuine attorney-client communications from discovery.
The secondary danger is equally serious: AI tools have no accountability for accuracy. ChatGPT will confidently provide legal guidance that sounds plausible but is completely wrong, creating a false sense of security. When business owners then forward these AI-generated responses to their actual attorneys, they muddy the water with incorrect information, forcing the lawyer to spend time correcting misconceptions instead of building an actual strategy. This wastes money, delays case preparation, and undermines the collaborative relationship between client and counsel that litigation demands.
"ChatGPT will tell you anything that you want to hear. Your prompt that you put into OpenAI is discoverable in litigation."
Brian Calhoun — Managing Partner, Calhoun Bhella LLP. Calhoun specializes in helping entrepreneurs and business owners with acquisitions, sales, corporate matters, and litigation. He founded Calhoun Bhella LLP in 2010 after working as a senior associate at major law firms in California and Dallas, initially launching the firm to focus exclusively on litigation before expanding into transactional practice.
The distinction between "discoverable" and "privileged" is fundamental to how litigation works in the United States. Communications between a client and an attorney made for the purpose of seeking or providing legal advice are protected from disclosure—they stay confidential and cannot be forced into evidence. But as Calhoun details in the episode, any communication with a public AI service is not confidential in the same way. Those prompts and responses exist on OpenAI's servers, are not covered by attorney-client privilege, and are therefore fully discoverable.
Full answer and detailsRead the whole answer, key facts and every other question from this episode
In short
Business owners should avoid relying on AI-generated content like ChatGPT for litigation matters because prompts entered into OpenAI are discoverable in court and receive no protection under attorney-client privilege or work product doctrine.
Brian Calhoun · Helping Business Owners Navigate Legal Challenges with Confidence (Brian Calhoun (Managing Partner) & Blake Brownshadel (Partner), Calhoun Bhella LLP) · The Think Small Podcast · answer at 14:00
Key takeaways
- Sending AI-generated responses to your attorney creates false expectations and clutters the legal strategy with unreliable information courts increasingly treat as ordinary business records, not privileged communications.
- The core problem lies in how legal discovery works.
- The secondary danger is equally serious: AI tools have no accountability for accuracy.
- Brian Calhoun — Managing Partner, Calhoun Bhella LLP.
- The distinction between "discoverable" and "privileged" is fundamental to how litigation works in the United States.
Quote to remember
“ChatGPT will tell you anything that you want to hear. Your prompt that you put into OpenAI is discoverable in litigation.”
— Brian Calhoun
The full answer · about 2 min
Business owners should avoid relying on AI-generated content like ChatGPT for litigation matters because prompts entered into OpenAI are discoverable in court and receive no protection under attorney-client privilege or work product doctrine. Sending AI-generated responses to your attorney creates false expectations and clutters the legal strategy with unreliable information courts increasingly treat as ordinary business records, not privileged communications.
The core problem lies in how legal discovery works. When litigation begins, as Brian Calhoun explains in this episode, any written communication between you and your attorney—or between you and third parties about your legal situation—becomes fair game for opposing counsel to request. If you generated that content using a public AI service like ChatGPT, that entire chain of prompts and responses can be subpoenaed and introduced as evidence. Courts are increasingly ruling that searches and prompts using open AI platforms lack the confidentiality protection that shields genuine attorney-client communications from discovery.
The secondary danger is equally serious: AI tools have no accountability for accuracy. ChatGPT will confidently provide legal guidance that sounds plausible but is completely wrong, creating a false sense of security. When business owners then forward these AI-generated responses to their actual attorneys, they muddy the water with incorrect information, forcing the lawyer to spend time correcting misconceptions instead of building an actual strategy. This wastes money, delays case preparation, and undermines the collaborative relationship between client and counsel that litigation demands.
"ChatGPT will tell you anything that you want to hear. Your prompt that you put into OpenAI is discoverable in litigation."
Brian Calhoun — Managing Partner, Calhoun Bhella LLP. Calhoun specializes in helping entrepreneurs and business owners with acquisitions, sales, corporate matters, and litigation. He founded Calhoun Bhella LLP in 2010 after working as a senior associate at major law firms in California and Dallas, initially launching the firm to focus exclusively on litigation before expanding into transactional practice.
The distinction between "discoverable" and "privileged" is fundamental to how litigation works in the United States. Communications between a client and an attorney made for the purpose of seeking or providing legal advice are protected from disclosure—they stay confidential and cannot be forced into evidence. But as Calhoun details in the episode, any communication with a public AI service is not confidential in the same way. Those prompts and responses exist on OpenAI's servers, are not covered by attorney-client privilege, and are therefore fully discoverable.
More answers from this episode
- 6:30What services does a boutique law firm focused on entrepreneurs offer compared to traditional big law practices?
- 11:00How does client involvement in litigation cases improve case outcomes and reduce legal costs?
- 21:00What are the risks of relying on AI case law citations in legal proceedings?
- 22:00What disclosure requirements are courts implementing regarding AI-generated legal documents?
- 22:30What is the impact of using ChatGPT to review transactional documents during deal negotiations?