What is the impact of using ChatGPT to review transactional documents during deal negotiations?
Answered at 22:30 in Helping Business Owners Navigate Legal Challenges with Confidence (Brian Calhoun (Managing Partner) & Blake Brownshadel (Partner), Calhoun Bhella LLP) · The Think Small Podcast
What is the impact of using ChatGPT to review transactional documents during deal negotiations?
When clients use ChatGPT to review contracts before attorney review, the tool typically generates 10 to 20 flagged issues, but only two or three are valid insights the attorney wasn't already planning to address. This forces lawyers to spend extra time addressing non-substantive AI-generated concerns alongside the opposing party's actual comments, directly inflating client costs and potentially delaying deal closure.
The problem lies in how AI processes contractual language. ChatGPT generates queries and observations based on pattern recognition, not legal judgment. A contract review tool cannot distinguish between a genuinely problematic clause and a boilerplate provision that poses no real risk to the transaction.
When a client presents an attorney with both the opposing side's revisions and a long list of ChatGPT-flagged concerns, the attorney must methodically address each one—a process that consumes billable hours. Each non-substantive issue requires the same time investment as a legitimate legal point, since the lawyer must evaluate and explain why it is or isn't a true concern.
As Brian Calhoun explains in the full episode, this dynamic compounds negotiation friction. Clients who insert AI-generated commentary into back-and-forth exchanges create additional rounds of clarification, extending timelines and increasing overall legal spend.
The Hidden Cost: False Positives in Deal Flow
The 10-to-20 output rate from ChatGPT is not accidental—it reflects the tool's design. AI tools are trained to err on the side of verbosity, offering multiple angles and observations to appear thorough. In a transactional context, this behavior is counterproductive.
Full answer and detailsRead the whole answer, key facts and every other question from this episode
In short
When clients use ChatGPT to review contracts before attorney review, the tool typically generates 10 to 20 flagged issues, but only two or three are valid insights the attorney wasn't already planning to address.
Brian Calhoun · Helping Business Owners Navigate Legal Challenges with Confidence (Brian Calhoun (Managing Partner) & Blake Brownshadel (Partner), Calhoun Bhella LLP) · The Think Small Podcast · answer at 22:30
Key takeaways
- This forces lawyers to spend extra time addressing non-substantive AI-generated concerns alongside the opposing party's actual comments, directly inflating client costs and potentially delaying deal closure.
- The problem lies in how AI processes contractual language.
- When a client presents an attorney with both the opposing side's revisions and a long list of ChatGPT-flagged concerns, the attorney must methodically address each one—a process that consumes billable hours.
- As Brian Calhoun explains in the full episode, this dynamic compounds negotiation friction.
- The 10-to-20 output rate from ChatGPT is not accidental—it reflects the tool's design.
The full answer · about 3 min
When clients use ChatGPT to review contracts before attorney review, the tool typically generates 10 to 20 flagged issues, but only two or three are valid insights the attorney wasn't already planning to address. This forces lawyers to spend extra time addressing non-substantive AI-generated concerns alongside the opposing party's actual comments, directly inflating client costs and potentially delaying deal closure.
The problem lies in how AI processes contractual language. ChatGPT generates queries and observations based on pattern recognition, not legal judgment. A contract review tool cannot distinguish between a genuinely problematic clause and a boilerplate provision that poses no real risk to the transaction.
When a client presents an attorney with both the opposing side's revisions and a long list of ChatGPT-flagged concerns, the attorney must methodically address each one—a process that consumes billable hours. Each non-substantive issue requires the same time investment as a legitimate legal point, since the lawyer must evaluate and explain why it is or isn't a true concern.
As Brian Calhoun explains in the full episode, this dynamic compounds negotiation friction. Clients who insert AI-generated commentary into back-and-forth exchanges create additional rounds of clarification, extending timelines and increasing overall legal spend.
The Hidden Cost: False Positives in Deal Flow
The 10-to-20 output rate from ChatGPT is not accidental—it reflects the tool's design. AI tools are trained to err on the side of verbosity, offering multiple angles and observations to appear thorough. In a transactional context, this behavior is counterproductive.
More answers from this episode
- 6:30What services does a boutique law firm focused on entrepreneurs offer compared to traditional big law practices?
- 11:00How does client involvement in litigation cases improve case outcomes and reduce legal costs?
- 14:00How should business owners approach using AI-generated legal content when facing litigation?
- 21:00What are the risks of relying on AI case law citations in legal proceedings?
- 22:00What disclosure requirements are courts implementing regarding AI-generated legal documents?